About this trip idea

Hoosier Pie Trail

Because of its historical significance to Indiana'’s heritage, the Sugar Cream Pie is often referred to as Indiana's State Pie. However, Hoosiers don’'t like or create only one type of pie. Follow this popular trail across the state to find all types. Maybe you like berry pie, chocolate pie, coconut pie, lemon pie or the traditional apple pie. The varieties are endless so you better start now!

Ahlemeyer Farms Olde Tyme Bakery

Ahlemeyer Farms is a quaint, local bakery in Columbus Indiana. They sell a variety of cookies, pies, breads and other baked goods.All of the delicious pies are made from scratch where pie shells are hand mixed and rolled out. They are also made using farm fresh ingredients and consist almost entirely of local fruit.


Anita's Kitchen

Anita’s Kitchen is a family owned, small town restaurant located in Pendleton, Indiana. Their menu includes breakfast all day, daily specials, throwback Thursdays, and freshly baked desserts!

Apple Dumpling Orchard at McClure’s Orchard
The pleasant lunch room and gift shop at McClure's Orchard is across from the Apple Barn, and features homemade apple products and baked goods on the menu as well as an excellent chicken salad, soups, sandwiches and of course, apple dumplings. Take home some applesauce or a basket of apples to prolong the country experience.


Apple Hill Orchard

Apple Hill's full service bakery makes wonderful pies and other treats daily. Located in Bruceville, their produce and bakery items can be purchased from July to December!


Blue Gate Restaurant

When you visit the Blue Gate Restaurant & Bakery in Shipshewana, you will enjoy a warm and inviting atmosphere, great home-style cooking, friendly service and all the baked goods your heart desires. While your table is being prepared, enjoy a peaceful Shipshewana moment on one of the many gliders that line their beautiful wrap-around porch.

Bread Basket Cafe & Bakery

Bread and bakery goods are the culinary must-haves at this small-town, big-taste restaurant. Using locally grown and organic ingredients whenever possible, this family business serves up decadent desserts, made-from-scratch soups and handcrafted bread in large proportions.


Bread Box Cafe

The Bread Box Bakery and Cafe , located in the Heart of Shipshewana, Indiana has been serving Scratch-baked traditional foods since 1984.  The mission of the Bread Box Bakery has always been to offer a unique dining experience to each customer. Whether stopping in for a favorite baked good or lingering over a bowl of homemade soup, the goal of Bread Box Cafe  is for each person to take home a special memory.


The Cabbage Rose Eatery and Gift Shop

 The Cabbage Rose Eatery and Gift Shop, located in Anderson serves new American cuisine. Stop by for lunch and try one some of their chicken velvet soup and one of their delicious cupcakes.


Caruso’s Italian Restaurant

Established in 1976, Caruso’s  is a family owned and operated restaurant. They serve traditional family recipes along with the latest trends in Italian cuisine and seafood. Stop in for a fresh fish entree or a gourmet pizza.


Clay’s Family Restaurant

Clay's is a family owned restaurant that has been a Steuben county tradition since 1950. Your hosts, The Baker family, are dedicated to the highest standards of both food and service.


Everett’s Place

Everett’sPlace serves delicious breakfast and lunch in Winchester Indiana. Their food is made-from-scratch cooking that’s perfect for the whole family.


Gray Brother’s Cafeteria

 Gray Brothers Cafeteria , located in Mooresville has been serving Indiana some of the best home cooked meals and desserts since 1944. With the same hard work, dedication, and great food, Gray Brothers Catering Service would be the perfect touch to your special day.


Julie’s Tell Street Cafe

Enjoy the small town charm at Julie’s Tell Street Cafe ! Sit down and enjoy yourself where you’ll be greeted by their friendly staff. Try some of the best pie in Tell City at Julie’s Tell Street Cafe.


Koffee Kup Diner

Eat local, home cooked food at this Portland Gem! During your visit, you must try the Breaded Tenderloin and Beef and Noodles! The pie and desserts are plentiful at Koffee Kup Diner . From Sugar Cream to Black Raspberry to Coconut Cream, the pies are a must order!


Lisa’s Pie Shop

Enjoy award winning pies, baked goods and pies in a jar at Lisa’s Pie Shop! Lisa’s Pie Shop offers the finest homemade pies from the country. However, there is one surprise, they come in a jar.


Mrs. Wick’s Pie

Wick’s has evolved into one of the most respected quality bakeries in the industry, and delivers its products to over 25 states in the United States. Wick’s is best known for their old fashioned sugar cream pies, which is produced from a Wickersham family recipe that dates back to the 19th Century farm. Wick's has been in the baking business for over 60 years, offering to the foodservice and bakery industry, as well as the consumer, the highest quality bakery products available.


Next Door Neighbor Deli & Bakery

Enjoy a new take on fruitcakes at Next Door Neighbor Deli & Bakery .You’ve never tasted fruitcakes like the chocolate and tropical ones made by Deb! Her fruitcakes are available in several flavors and made fresh from scratch.


Oasis Diner

Take a trip back in time to the 1950s at Oasis Diner . Oasis Diner is one of the hottest places to get disco fries and a chocolate malt on the west side! With an impressive menu, the Oasis Diner doesn’t disappoint. Be sure to an Oasis Burger,  a messy number topped with pulled pork, bacon, and coleslaw

Rosie’s Place

Rosies Place is a warm, inviting cafe on the square in Noblesville, Indiana. Featuring homemade, mid-western inspired fare, Rosies is a gathering place for friends and families.Rosies believes in serving good, honest food prepared with fresh, local, and seasonal ingredients. Their menu changes daily and seasonally, in order to bring you the best selection of items at their peak. They promote local, Indiana farmers products and use no artificial ingredients or preservatives in all their recipes.


The Flour Basket Bakery & Cafe

The Flour Basket Cakery & Cafe is a bakery and antique shop located in Rockville. Enjoy made From scratch pies, noodles and other homestyle food.