The Edinburgh Pixy Theatre was built in 1907 to be used as a Masonic Lodge which remained it's primary use until 2008. It was paid for by Masonic members who purchased "shares" for $25.00 each. The Rainbow Girls and Eastern Star also met there; The theatre has been a former opera house, movie theater, and home of the Edinburgh Sugar Creek Players for nearly 20 years.

Following its acquisition in July of 2008, the former Masonic Lodge/Pixy Theatre has undergone extensive renovation and now serves as a unique historical venue for live music, arts, stage productions, weddings, and events for the community of Edinburgh.