The Indiana Insider Blog

Indiana’s Super 46 Sandwich List – Bring It On! (#Super46)

Everybody has to eat! And, especially football fans in February when they converge on Indianapolis for Super Bowl XLVI. To commemorate the big game, the Publishers of Indianapolis Monthly Magazine have picked 46 Super Sandwiches that will have your taste buds coming back for more.

And, we are not the only ones who think so. Many of these sandwiches have been featured in Gourmet magazine or on the Food Network’s Diners, Drive-ins and Dives. Like The Original Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich at Nick’s Kitchen (Huntington), The Duane Purvis All-American Burger at the Triple XXX Family Restaurant (West Lafayette) and the Meatball Sub at The Historic Steer-In (Indianapolis) to name a few of Indiana’s famous feasts.

These Super 46 are sure to give you something to cheer about whether you are going to the big game or not.

So, whether you try one or try them all, you are going to love this Indiana food experience. We suggest making it this year’s New Year resolution!

Drum roll, please…And, the winners are…

Boathouse Grill, Indianapolis Fish Submarine
Boogie Burger, Indianapolis Boogie Monster
Bourbon Street Distrillery, Indianapolis Triple Decker BLT
Broad Ripple Brew Pub, Indianapolis Veggie Mushroom Burger
Bub’s Burgers and Ice Cream, Carmel The “Settle for Less Ugly Elk” Quarter Pound
Café Patachou, Indianapolis Broken Yolk Sandwiches
Carniceria Guanajuato, Indianapolis Torta Milenese
Creation Café, Indianapolis Southern Style BBQ Sandwich
Fair Oaks Dairy, Fair Oaks Grilled Cheese Sandwich
FARMbloomington Restaurant, Bloomington Lugar Burger
Gerst Bavarian Haus, Evansville Schweinefilet Sandwich
Ghyslain Richmond Bistro, Richmond Pan Bagnat Nicoise
Gnaw Mart, Gnaw Bone Gnaw Bone Tenderloin
Goose the Market, Indianapolis The Batali
Harry & Izzy’s, Indianapolis St. Elmo Prime Rib Sandwich
Hinkle’s Sandwich Shop, Madison Hamburger
Hoaglin To Go & Marketplace, Indianapolis Take You Back PB&J
Hobnob Corner Restaurant, Nashville Pot Roast Sandwich
Judge’s Tip of the Rib, Indianapolis Pulled Pork Sandwich
Marble’s Café, Indianapolis Chicken Club
Mug n Bun, Indianapolis Breaded Tenderloin
Nick’s Kitchen, Huntington The Original Breaded Pork Tenderloin Sandwich
Nickel Plate Bar & Grille, Fishers Breaded Tenderloin
Northside Kitchenette, Indianapolis The Munchie Supreme
Opie Taylor’s, Bloomington Tom Crean & Crimson Burger
Original Gyro Joint, Indianapolis Original Gyro
Papa Roux, Indianapolis Roast Pork Po’ Boy
Plump’s Last Shot, Indianapolis Tenderloin
Rock Cola 50s Café, Indianapolis Mile High Club Sandwich
Saigon Restaurant, Indianapolis Banh Mi Thit Nuong
Schnitzelbank, Jasper Bratwurst
Shapiro’s  Delicatessen, Indianapolis Reuben
Super Tortas estilo Barrio, Indianapolis Super Torta Cubana
Taste Café & Marketplace, Indianapolis Curried Chicken Salad
The Barking Dog Café, Indianapolis Buddy’s Shrimp Roll
The Bosphorus, Indianapolis Falafel Sandwich
The Friendly Tavern, Zionsville Hoosier Classic Tenderloin
The Historic Steer-In, Indianapolis Meatball Sub
The Local Eatery & Pub, Westfield Beef Tongue Cheese Steak
The Rathskeller, Indianapolis Frikadelle
The Streamliner Family Restaurant, Rochester Ultimate Grilled Tenderloin
The Working Man’s Friend, Indianapolis Double Cheeseburger
Tortas Guicho Dominguez y El Cubanito, Indianapolis Cubana
Triple XXX, West Lafayette The Duane Purvis All-American
Upland Brewing Company, Bloomington Seitan Tenderloin
Zaharakos, Columbus The Gom Sandwich

Log on to and get eatin’! Even take the list on the run. is mobile.

Tagged as: