Home Best of Indiana The Winners: Your Top Ten Favorites Indiana's Best Ice Cream And here’s where to find Indiana’s best ice cream. These 10 ice cream shops were selected by voters as the best in Indiana. Get to one, lickety split! The Chief Ice CreamThe Chief Ice Cream 502 West Lincoln Ave. Goshen, IN 46526 (574) 534-6410 The Chief Ice Cream is an unasuming stand in Goshen, Indiana producing some of the best ice cream in the country! The long lines are worth it for their world class ice cream! Valpo VelvetValpo Velvet 57 Monroe Street Valparaiso, IN 46383(219) 464-4141 Valp Velvet offers over 60 flavors of ice cream made from fresh, local ingredients. Check out their changing flavors and products that are always high quality. South Side Soda ShopSouth Side Soda Shop 1122 South Main Street Goshen, IN 46526 (574) 534-3790 South Side Soda Shop is a picturesque American classic diner. Finish off your meal with sundae, float, or milkshake! IvanhoesIvanhoes 979 S Main Street. Upland, IN 46989 (765) 998-7261 Ivanhoes has 100 different ice cream sundaes on their menu! If you try all 100 varieties, you can be a memeber of their '100 Club'! Fair Oaks FarmFair Oaks Farm 856 N 600 E. Fair Oaks, IN 47943 (877) 536-1194 Website Escape to the country with outdoor fun, food and learning where you can explore family farms and reconnect with nature animals and our planet. Rocket Science Ice CreamRocket Science Ice Cream401 E. Main St. Nappanee, IN 46550(574) 773-7003 This ice cream shop creates their ice cream with liquid nitrogen! After the flavors are combined, watch it turn to ice cream as liquid nitrogen is poured over top for a fun science lesson! Hartzell's Ice CreamHartzell's Ice Cream107 N Dunn St.Bloomington, IN 47408(812) 332-3502 Hartzell's is a local favorite, offering sweet treats for everyone! Have a scoop in one of their homemade waffle cones! DeBrand Fine ChocolatesDeBrand Fine Chocolates878 Harrison St. Fort Wayne, IN 46802(260) 969-8353 Website In the mood for some chocolate? Check out DeBrand Fine Chocolates in one of their 4 Fort Wayne locations. Try a sundae with their homemade ice cream topped with gourmet chocolate. Sycamore Drive-InSycamore Drive-In 923 W Washington StreetMonticello, IN 47960 (574) 583-3700 This hidden gem has a huge variety of homemade ice cream, milkshakes, custard, and sundaes! Zaharakos Ice Cream ParlorZaharakos 329 Washington Street Columbus, IN 47201 (812) 378-1900 Zaharakos isn't just a classic ice cream parlor, it's also a museum! Learn about old fashioned soda fountains in a beautiful historical location. Afterwards, sample some of their delicious ice cream.