Indiana's Best Pie

Take the family to one of these Indiana restaurants for a slice of pie that was voted Your Ten Favorite! Even better, buy a whole pie to take home with you.

Apple Pie- The Apple Works Trafalgar

The Apple Works
8157 South 250 West
Trafalgar, IN 46181
(317) 878-9317

The Apple Works Double Crust Dutch Apple Pie is a slice of heaven! Their orchards grow over 50 varieties of apples, and they produce all kinds of apple products. 

Apple Pie a la mode- Apple Hill Orchard

Apple Hill Orchard
6235 N Ford Rd.
Bruceville, IN 47516
(812) 324-9010

Website

Apple Hill's full service bakery makes wonderful pies and other treats daily. The spacious loft in our beautiful log cabin is also available for rent. This is a great location for parties, dinners, showers, and meetings. The loft will seat 80-90 indoors and another 50 outside on the deck overlooking the orchard.

Sugar Cream Pie- Wick's Pies

Wick's Pies Inc.
217 SE Greenville Ave.
Winchester, IN 47394
(765) 584-8401

Website

Tour Wick's bakery and observe the making and baking of pies and pie shells. Tours available by appointment. Pie shop open year-round.

Sugar Cream Pie- Clifty Inn

Clifty Inn at Clifty Falls State Park
1650 Clifty Hollow Road
Madison, IN 47250
(812) 265-4135

Website

Sample some pie in the perfect scenic location of Clifty Falls State Park. Try a slice at their brunch buffet or a sweet ending to dinner!

Peanut Butter Pie- Old Richmond Inn

Old Richmond Inn
138 South 5th Street
Richmond, IN 47374
(765) 962-2247

Peanut Butter and Whipped Cream on Dark Chocolate Cookie Crust and Topped with a Thin Layer of Semi-Sweet Chocolate.

Pecan Pie- Fort Harrison State Park Inn

Fort Harrison State Park Inn
5830 N Post Road
Indiannapolis, IN 46216
(317) 638-6000

Website

Set in this historic inn, Fort Harrison State Park Inn's hidden gem is their pecan pie.

Berry Pie- Das Dutchman Essenhaus

Das Dutchman Essenhaus
240 US 20
Middlebury, IN 46540
(800) 455-9471

Website

With 1100 seats, our Amish-style restaurant specializes in hospitality and quality. Crisp broasted chicken, 30 types of pie, and everything in between.

Cobbler- Stone Hearth Cafe

Stone Hearth Cafe
2131 North Centreville
Centreville, IN 47330
(765) 855-2000

 

Inside the Warm Glow Candle Co. Store, this café is known for its pies! Enjoy a slice after doing some shopping at the candle store!

Shoefly & Pumpkin Pie- Amish Acres

Amish Acres Historic Farm and Heritage Resort
1600 Market Street
Nappanee, IN 46550
(800) 800-4942

Website

The complete Amish heritage experience. National register of Historic Places, farmstead tours, wagon rides, threshers dinner, Broadway musicals, and shops!

Mini Peanut Butter Pie- Abe Martin Lodge

Abe Martin Lodge
1810 SR 46 E 
Nashville, IN 47448
(877) 265-6343

Website

Scenic Brown County State Park welcomes all visitors with its rolling hills and scenic vistas. Abe Martin Lodge inside the park offers comfortable lodging in both lodge and cabins. All ages will enjoy the indoor aquatic center with its slide, lazy river, and hot tub. Mountain bike trails voted one of the best in the United States. Nearby downtown Nashville offers Hoosier style shopping opportunities. See the park on 4 legs, and visit our saddlebarn.The Lodge offers many hotel packages.