Home Best of Indiana Winners Best Pies The Winners Are... Share this: Twitter Facebook View on Map Print 1 Apple Pie Apple Pie The Apple Works 8157 S 250 WTrafalgar, IN 46181(317) 878-9317 2 Apple Pie a la mode Apple Pie a la mode Apple Hill Orchard 6235 N Ford RdBruceville, IN 47516(812) 324-9010 Read more 3 Sugar Cream Pie Sugar Cream Pie Wick’s Pie 217 SE Greenville AveWinchester, IN 47394(765) 584-8401 Read more 4 Sugar Cream Pie Sugar Cream Pie Clifty Inn at Clifty Falls State Park 1650 Clifty Hollow RdMadison, IN 47250(812) 265-4135 Read more 5 Peanut Butter Pie Peanut Butter Pie Olde Richmond Inn 138 S 5th StRichmond, IN 47374(765) 962-2247 6 Pecan Pie Pecan Pie Fort Harrison State Park Inn 5830 N Post RdIndianapolis, IN 46216(317) 638-6000 Read more 7 Berry Pie Berry Pie Das Dutchman Essenhaus 240 U.S. 20Middlebury, IN 46540(574) 825-9471 Read more 8 Variety of Cobblers Variety of Cobblers Stone Hearth Café 2131 N Centerville RdCenterville, IN 47330(765) 855-2233 9 Shoo-fly or Pumpkin Pie Shoo-fly or Pumpkin Pie Amish Acres 1600 W Market StNappanee, IN 46550(574) 773-4188 Read more 10 Mini Peanut Butter Pie Mini Peanut Butter Pie Abe Martin Lodge at Brown County State Park 1405 State Road 46 WestNashville, IN 47448(812) 988-4418 Read more